It’s Benjamin Netanyahu That is Delegitimizing Israel


The peace-loving PM of Israel

The new buzzword from the Israel Lobby, the media, the Jewish community and sadly, our government, is “delegitimization.” It’s essentially nothing more than propaganda used at the behest of the Israeli government but unfortunately, it’s made our way into our policies in the Middle East. Barack Obama uses the term, Secretary Clinton uses the term, members of Congress, and on and on.

I personally believe the word was created to prevent the U.S. and Israel from having to make good on the promise to recognize Palestinian nonviolence. Back in the day when the PLO was actively involved in terrorism, we implored the Palestinians to renounce violence and find a more appropriate way of getting their message heard. Well, now many of them have done that and what have we done in response? Labeled them “delegitimizers” of Israel.

To make matters worse, the U.S. and Israeli governments have the audacity to breathlessly claim that delegitimization is a threat to Israel’s very existence! In fact, the State Dept. has proudly proclaimed that they will battle delegitimization wherever they find it. Good luck with that. Ever notice that pretty much everything is labeled a threat to Israel’s existence? Except, of course, their own actions.

That is the theme of MJ Rosenberg’s latest article over at HuffPo. Here’s an excerpt:

The “pro-Israel” lobby’s latest hobbyhorse is “delegitimization.” Those who criticize Israeli policies are accused of trying to “delegitimize” Israel, which supposedly means denying Israel’s right to exist. Even President Obama has gotten into the act, stating in his May 19 speech that “for the Palestinians, efforts to delegitimize Israel will end in failure.”

[snip]

In that context, the whole idea of “delegitimizing” Israel sounds silly. Israel can’t be delegitimized.

So what is the lobby talking about?

The answer is simple: It is talking about the intensifying opposition to the occupation of the West Bank and the blockade of Gaza which, by almost any standard, is illegitimate. It is talking about opposition to the settlements, which are not only illegitimate but illegal under international law. It is talking about calls for Israel to grant Palestinians equal rights.

The lobby’s determination to change the subject from the existence of the occupation to the existence of Israel makes sense strategically. Israel has no case when it comes to the occupation, which the entire world (except Israel) agrees must end. But Israel certainly has the upper hand in any argument over its right to exist and to defend itself.

That is why Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu routinely invokes Israel’s “right to self-defense” every time he tries to explain away some Israeli attack on Palestinians, no matter whether they are armed fighters or innocent civilians. If the whole Israeli-Palestinian discussion is about Israel’s right to defend itself, Israel wins the argument. But if it is about the occupation — which is, in fact, what the conflict has been about since 1993 when the PLO recognized Israel — it loses.

It wasn’t that long ago that neither the Israeli government nor the lobby worried about the “forces of delegitimization.”

On the contrary, in 1993, following Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s recognition of the Palestinians’ right to a state in the West Bank and Gaza, nine non-Arab Muslim states and 32 of the 43 sub-Saharan African states established relations with Israel. India and China, the two largest markets in the world, opened trade relations. Jordan signed a peace treaty and several of the Arab emirates began quiet dealings with Israel.

The Arab boycott of Israel ended. Foreign investment soared. No one discussed “delegitimization” while much of the world, including the Muslim world, was knocking on Israel’s door to establish or deepen ties.

That trend continued so long as the Israeli government seemed to be genuinely engaged in the peace process.

[snip]

The world mourned Rabin because under him, Israel had embraced the cause of peace with the Palestinians. The homage to Rabin was a clear demonstration — as was the opening of trade and diplomatic relations with formerly hostile states — that Israel was not being isolated because it is a Jewish state and hence illegitimate, but because of how it treated the Palestinians.

[snip]

Once again, Israel’s “best friends” are among its worst enemies.

[emphasis added]

And that about sums it up. It seems so obvious, doesn’t it? And yet not one single bozo in the MSM points out something so basic. Not one single member of the MSM has ever asked Secretary Clinton or President Obama about how “delegitimization” is nothing but an attempt to silence critics of the Occupation. NOT ONE.

The implications of the propaganda campaign of screaming “delegitimization” every five minutes essentially means that the U.S. government is promoting the view/policy that all people have a right to nonviolent protest, free speech, human rights and free association except the Palestinians. Now THAT is truly radical indeed.

Advertisements
, , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Stacy

Attorney, Publisher, Foreign Policy wonk

View all posts by Stacy

Subscribe

Subscribe to our RSS feed and social profiles to receive updates.

5 Comments on “It’s Benjamin Netanyahu That is Delegitimizing Israel”

  1. thainjacobs Says:

    It’s totally depressing to hear this administration talk like they are reading right from AIPAC’s script.

    I’m sort of fed up with the lot of them. They’re all chickenhawks more concerned with doing what is easy rather than what is right.

    Did you see the warning the State Dept. sent out that was clearly aimed at any Americans who might dare to be on the Flotilla II headed to Gaza. It sounds a lot like they don’t give a shit if Israel kills people and we can fully expect the administration to respond by saying “we warned you!”

    When you consider how much time this admin has spent kissing Israel’s ass, I don’t know how anyone could blame the Palestinians or the arab world if they told us to f*ck off and take their chances at the UN.

    MJ Rosenberg is right, as he says it all comes down to this:

    It wasn’t that long ago that neither the Israeli government nor the lobby worried about the “forces of delegitimization.”

    On the contrary, in 1993, following Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s recognition of the Palestinians’ right to a state in the West Bank and Gaza, nine non-Arab Muslim states and 32 of the 43 sub-Saharan African states established relations with Israel. India and China, the two largest markets in the world, opened trade relations. Jordan signed a peace treaty and several of the Arab emirates began quiet dealings with Israel.

    The Arab boycott of Israel ended. Foreign investment soared. No one discussed “delegitimization” while much of the world, including the Muslim world, was knocking on Israel’s door to establish or deepen ties.

    Why doesn’t the media point that out? Stacy has been saying this for the past two plus years- if Israel would allow a fair resolution of the conflict then the Arab League member states would normalize relations with Israel- THAT is what will keep Israel safe, not running around shooting everything that moves and sabre-ratting with Iran and Lebanon. But no, no one in the media or pundit class brings up that painfully obvious point.

    We need more Arabs in the media. Clearly our MSM has a conflict of interest when they report on Israel.

    Reply

  2. seamus6 Says:

    HA! you all can run but you can’t hide!

    Very nice blog Stacy. I enjoy the template. Very clean looking and not all junked up with stuff. Although I do think where Bibi is concerned, a Blingee picture is warranted. So next time lets have some fun with glitter, shall we?

    Reply

  3. Pilgrim Says:

    I am glad to have learned about this site. I agree with Seamus that it is very attractively presented.

    Reply

Leave a Response

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: