Every Media Outlet Proclaims Israel Accepts Quartet Statement to Return to Negotiations Without Preconditions But Leaves Out Israel’s Demand for Preconditions

This is so frustrating but predictable.

I did a search of major news sources- Washington post, MSNBC, NYT, Reuters and even read the State Department press briefing from yesterday and with the exception of the Israeli Daily Haaretz, all are reporting Israel will return to negotiations based on the Quartet statement and is urging the Palestinians to do so without preconditions (see google results for this here). Here’s the problem- since the Quartet released it’s statement about 2 weeks ago Israel has been in constant contact with the U.S. trying to get clarification and assurances about what the statement does and doesn’t mean. According to Israeli officials, Bibi Netanyahu is quietly adding on his own list of preconditions to the Quartet statement if negotiations resume- I wrote a post about this the other day, here.

The implications of this are obvious- laud the Israelis for their flexibility and willingness to negotiate while casting the Palestinians as inflexible refuseniks. And round and round we go, where it stops nobody knows.

In addition, the media and commentators have made much of the fact that the Palestinian bid at the UN violates prior agreements between the parties. Well, guess what? Israel is in violation of prior agreements regarding settlements:

…Netanyahu depends on the fact that his tenants – namely, you, the citizens – won’t take the time to read the fine print in the Quartet’s document and won’t ask unnecessary questions. The main thing is that the media will report to the world that Israel has “adopted” the plan and is calling on the Palestinians to follow in its footsteps.

How many people will notice that the Quartet’s plan, which the government is now “happy to advance,” states that the authoritative source for the negotiations is a combination of Barack Obama’s May 19, 2011, speech, the 2003 Road Map and the Arab peace initiative of 2002? Who is able to pick out the differences between Obama’s speech to the U.S. Department of State and the ones he gave to AIPAC and to the UN? Who remembers that the Road Map requires that Israel freeze all construction in the settlements, including building to cater for the “natural growth” of the population, and dismantle the outposts immediately? Who is familiar with the Arab peace initiative, which recommends that in exchange for normalization of relations with the Arab states, Israel withdraws from the territories it conquered in 1967 (including the Golan Heights ) and lends a hand to a just and agreed-upon solution to the problem of refugees on the basis of UN Resolution 194?


Netanyahu has not changed his mind. The prime minister has learned from Ariel Sharon that there need not be a connection between accepting the Quartet’s plan and the facts on the ground. Even the UN Security Council’s decision to adopt the Road Map has not changed reality. Well, ok, it has changed; it’s taken a turn for the worse. Since the Israeli government “adopted” the Road Map plan in 2003, thousands of apartments have been added to the settlements, and the vast majority of outposts are still standing. And who is the American Congress punishing for breaching agreements by cutting aid? That’s right, the Palestinians, who dared to ask the UN to recognize their state.

[emphasis added]

, , , , , , ,

About Stacy

Attorney, Publisher, Foreign Policy wonk

View all posts by Stacy


Subscribe to our RSS feed and social profiles to receive updates.

2 Comments on “Every Media Outlet Proclaims Israel Accepts Quartet Statement to Return to Negotiations Without Preconditions But Leaves Out Israel’s Demand for Preconditions”

  1. Carolyn-Rodham Says:

    *tapping foot impatiently, eager to hear stacy’s reaction to Nicholas Kristof’s column in the NY Times this morning (“Is Israel it’s Own Worst Enemy?”).*


    • Stacy Says:

      Actually I hadn’t seen it so thanks for the heads up. I am crazy busy today so I will try to highlight the article in a post later this evening.

      And then on the other side of the coin we have this:


      All of this fear-mongering about losing Jewish support is the result of effective political messaging not only by the GOP but by the Israel lobby- this is how they get politicians and certainly Presidents to tow the Israel Right or Wrong line.

      To hear these folks talk and to read these articles you would think American Jews care about one iisue only- slavish devotion to Israel. That’s sort of condescending to Jews. It also has the effect of feeding into perception that Jewish Americans are more loyal to Israel than to the US, and that’s not good.

      The sad fact is though, this fear-mongering by the Israel lobby, some politicians and prominent Jewish organizations has had the effect of destroying any chance for mideast peace and ensured that our foreign policy in the Middle East continues to be a disaster- at our own peril. Of course, that was the goal of the lobby- to ensure Obama didn’t become even-handed in negotiations and to ensure that he would spend the rest of his presidency sounding like a member of Likud.

      Mission accomplished.


Leave a Response

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: